
The Houston City Council’s effort to codify Mayor John Whitmire’s executive order limiting police cooperation with ICE was blocked Tuesday after City Attorney Arturo Michel deemed the proposed ordinance unlawful, citing potential conflicts with state law.
The mayor’s executive order remains in effect despite the council’s failed legislative effort, and Houston Police Department officers are still complying with its terms, according to city officials. The policy, announced Nov. 6, directs HPD to cease contacting U.S. Immigration and Customs Enforcement about civil immigration warrants except when an individual is arrested for a jailable offense.
After Gov. Greg Abbott threatened to revoke more than $110 million in public safety funding, Houston police resumed detaining people while waiting for ICE to respond to civil immigration warrants, according to Houston Public Media.
City Attorney Arturo Michel said Senate Bill 4, the 2017 state law requiring local cooperation with federal immigration enforcement and banning sanctuary cities, supersedes the proposed ordinance. “SB 4 is still in effect. An ordinance that says you do not have to comply with SB 4 is unlawful,” Michel said during the Nov. 18 council meeting, according to Community Impact.
Council members Alejandra Salinas, Edward Pollard and Tiffany Thomas had used Proposition A to place the ordinance on the agenda, seeking to codify Whitmire’s executive order into law. In a joint statement Wednesday, the three said the proposed ordinance “mirrored the Mayor’s executive order language verbatim” and argued the city attorney overstepped his authority. “Courts, not an unelected city legal department, determine what is lawful. The City Attorney’s role is to advise, not stonewall Council’s authority,” they wrote.
The legal dispute follows a broader conflict between Houston and state officials over immigration enforcement. In April, the city first attempted to curb HPD’s cooperation with ICE.
Whitmire’s Nov. 6 order came days after Texas voters elected Democrats to all open statewide offices, including attorney general. On Friday, Texas Attorney General Ken Paxton’s office filed a motion in Fort Bend County District Court seeking to block the policy, arguing “a municipality may not undermine or subvert local law enforcement cooperation and communication with federal immigration enforcement, whether by decree or by legislation,” according to Houston Public Media.
Michel indicated the city may seek to delay litigation until Paxton leaves office in January. “It will be difficult for the Attorney General to obtain a court ruling before the new administration takes over, which has indicated it will not pursue SB4 enforcement of this nature,” Michel said, according to Houston Public Media. Incoming Attorney General Nathan Johnson, a Democrat, did not immediately respond to a question about whether he would allow Houston to implement Whitmire’s policy, Houston Public Media reported. Paxton’s office also did not immediately respond to a request for comment.
Whitmire defended his decision to issue the policy as an executive order rather than pursue council legislation. “What’s broken? The policy is in place, and it’s working, so let’s go forward,” Whitmire said, according to Community Impact. He added that he took a risk by issuing the order, noting the city has been sued.
Council members who supported the ordinance argued it is necessary to protect the policy from reversal by future administrations. Thomas questioned the administration’s opposition, asking, “The question in my head is why it was so important to be law of the land when the administration presented an ordinance… Why was it important to vote as a body … but it’s not important to do it when we have the political wins?” according to Community Impact.
Records show HPD officers contacted ICE nearly 200 times from April through September, including during traffic stops and while responding to emergency assistance calls, and handed over at least 36 people directly to ICE, according to Houston Public Media. Salinas urged Whitmire’s administration to defend the executive order in court, saying, “Ken Paxton is yet again trying to bully Houston into abandoning protections for our immigrant neighbors and families,” according to Houston Public Media.